OK

OK
Cancel
Not on FilmNet yet? Join now!
A Look Back
Search Reviews

Contribute your own review to FilmNet!

Share your own perspective with the readers of our reviews. You can add your own article as a response to any existing review on FilmNet.

Ararat

Released: 2002

Genre: Drama

Runtime: 1 hr 50 min

MPAA Rating: R

Director: Atom Egoyan

Starring: Simon Abkarian, Charles Aznavour, Christopher Plummer, Arsinée Khanjian, Setta Keshishian, David Alpay, Shant Srabian

Atom Egoyan film revolving around the Armenian Genocide.

Should have a greater impact than it does.

Review by: MiamiMovieCritic

Added: 10 years ago

Ararat tells an important, compelling story, but I’m not sure Atom Egoyan was the right filmmaker to tell it. The tragedy and horror of the Armenian Genocide provides more than enough material for a great film, but Egoyan has messed around with it, bringing his own artistic impulses to the table. The result is a movie that should have a greater impact than it does.

Egoyan’s biggest mistake is to frame the story as a movie-within-a-movie, so all the parts where Turkish soldiers are torturing, raping and slaughtering Armenian civilians are presented as scenes from a Hollywood epic. In other words, these depictions are NOT REAL. This would seem to run counter to the film’s modus operandi, which is to refute the Turkish government’s outrageous and shameful claims that the genocide never took place.

The central drama involves the son of an art historian (David Alpay) being interviewed by a customs agent. These scenes are very well acted and written, but I’m at a complete loss as to why Egoyan explores the personal lives of these characters. The suspect is having an incestuous affair with his stepsister – a theme that was central to The Sweet Hereafter but seems pretty arbitrary here. And the customs agent is unwilling to accept his son’s homosexuality – which is wrong, but I’m not sure it’s a very good metaphor for the kind of mass death and pure hatred that the Armenian Genocide represents. Egoyan makes movies that are mysteries and jigsaw puzzles, but sometimes his intentions are also a bit puzzling.

$_COOKIE

Request

action => 'detail'
controller => 'reviews'
module => 'reviews'
reviewAlias => 'ararat'

View vars

bandsFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/bands_files/'
baseDir => 'http://www.filmnet.com/'
channelFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/channel_files/'
festivalFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/festival_files/'
filmFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/film_files/'
filmcompanyFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/filmcompany_files/'
filmmakerFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/filmmaker_files/'
head =>
meta =>
items =>
0 =>
content => 'text/html; charset=utf-8'
http-equiv => 'Content-Type'
type => 'http-equiv'
1 =>
content => 'Ararat tells an important, compelling story, but I’m not sure Atom Egoyan was the right filmmaker to tell it.'
name => 'description'
type => 'name'
2 =>
content => 'Ararat, review, Should have a greater impact than it does.'
name => 'keywords'
type => 'name'
title => 'FilmNet - Reviews - Ararat'
lang => 'en'
locale => 'en_US'
movieFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/movie_files/'
musiciansFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/musicians_files/'
reviewFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/review_files/'
reviewsPage =>
detail-review =>
__attr__id => 77
__attr__is_staff_review => 1
__domel__body => '<p>Ararat tells an important, compelling story, but I’m not sure Atom Egoyan was the right filmmaker to tell it. The tragedy and horror of the Armenian Genocide provides more than enough material for a great film, but Egoyan has messed around with it, bringing his own artistic impulses to the table. The result is a movie that should have a greater impact than it does.</p> <p>Egoyan’s biggest mistake is to frame the story as a movie-within-a-movie, so all the parts where Turkish soldiers are torturing, raping and slaughtering Armenian civilians are presented as scenes from a Hollywood epic. In other words, these depictions are NOT REAL. This would seem to run counter to the film’s modus operandi, which is to refute the Turkish government’s outrageous and shameful claims that the genocide never took place.</p> <p>The central drama involves the son of an art historian (David Alpay) being interviewed by a customs agent. These scenes are very well acted and written, but I’m at a complete loss as to why Egoyan explores the personal lives of these characters. The suspect is having an incestuous affair with his stepsister – a theme that was central to The Sweet Hereafter but seems pretty arbitrary here. And the customs agent is unwilling to accept his son’s homosexuality – which is wrong, but I’m not sure it’s a very good metaphor for the kind of mass death and pure hatred that the Armenian Genocide represents. Egoyan makes movies that are mysteries and jigsaw puzzles, but sometimes his intentions are also a bit puzzling.</p>'
alias => 'ararat'
comments => 0
dt-publish => '10 years ago'
logo => 'logo.jpg'
movie =>
__attr__id => 43
description => 'Atom Egoyan film revolving around the Armenian Genocide.'
director => 'Atom Egoyan'
genre => 'Drama'
rated => 'R'
runtime => '1 hr 50 min'
starring => 'Simon Abkarian, Charles Aznavour, Christopher Plummer, Arsinée Khanjian, Setta Keshishian, David Alpay, Shant Srabian'
title => 'Ararat'
year => 2002
photos => 0
rating => 60
reviewer =>
__attr__id => 84
login => 'MiamiMovieCritic'
rss-link => 'reviews/classic/'
teaser => 'Should have a greater impact than it does.'
title => 'Ararat'
type-id => 7
user-reviews => 0
filters =>
0 =>
__attr__active_id => 1
__attr__as => 's'
__attr__id => 'review-sort-by-id'
items =>
0 =>
__attr__id => 1
name => 'Recently Added'
1 =>
__attr__id => 2
name => 'Alphabetical'
link => 'reviews/classic/?'
1 =>
__attr__active_id => 4
__attr__as => 'g'
__attr__id => 'review-genre-id'
items =>
0 =>
__attr__id => 0
name => 'All'
1 =>
__attr__id => 1
name => 'Action & Adventure'
2 =>
__attr__id => 2
name => 'Comedy'
3 =>
__attr__id => 3
name => 'Documentary'
4 =>
__attr__id => 4
name => 'Drama'
5 =>
__attr__id => 5
name => 'Experimental'
6 =>
__attr__id => 7
name => 'Horror'
7 =>
__attr__id => 9
name => 'Kids & Family'
8 =>
__attr__id => 6
name => 'Music'
9 =>
__attr__id => 13
name => 'Mystery & Suspense'
10 =>
__attr__id => 10
name => 'Romance'
11 =>
__attr__id => 11
name => 'Sci-Fi & Fantasy'
12 =>
__attr__id => 14
name => 'War'
link => 'reviews/classic/?'
2 =>
__attr__active_id => 'classic'
__attr__id => 'review-tab-id'
items =>
0 =>
__attr__id => 'updates'
name => 'Updates'
1 =>
__attr__id => 'filmnet'
name => 'On FilmNet'
2 =>
__attr__id => 'theaters'
name => 'In Theaters'
3 =>
__attr__id => 'dvd'
name => 'On DVD'
4 =>
__attr__id => 'classic'
name => 'A Look Back'
5 =>
__attr__id => 'interviews'
name => 'Interviews'
link => 'reviews/'
schoolFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/school_files/'
search =>
form-action => 'reviews'
userFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/user_files/'
videoFiles => 'http://i.filmnet.com/video_files/'

HTML Information

Tags
HTML Size: 36.96K
Stylesheet Files
Javascript Files
Images

Database queries

Metadata cache is DISABLED

Adapter 0

  1. [0.49 ms] connect
  2. [122.64 ms] SELECT `r`.*, `vr`.`video_id`, `cr`.`channel_id`, `ur`.`user_id`, `mr`.`movie_id` FROM `reviews` AS `r` LEFT JOIN `video__reviews` AS `vr` ON vr.review_id = r.review_id LEFT JOIN `channel__reviews` AS `cr` ON cr.review_id = r.review_id LEFT JOIN `user__reviews` AS `ur` ON ur.review_id = r.review_id LEFT JOIN `movie__reviews` AS `mr` ON mr.review_id = r.review_id WHERE (review_alias = 'ararat')
  3. [0.69 ms] SELECT `users`.* FROM `users` WHERE (user_id='84')
  4. [1.87 ms] SELECT `m`.* FROM `movies` AS `m` WHERE (movie_id = '43')
  5. [24.95 ms] SELECT COUNT(DISTINCT(r.review_id)) AS `cnt`, `vr`.`video_id`, `cr`.`channel_id`, `ur`.`user_id`, `mr`.`movie_id`, 1 FROM `reviews` AS `r` LEFT JOIN `video__reviews` AS `vr` ON vr.review_id = r.review_id LEFT JOIN `channel__reviews` AS `cr` ON cr.review_id = r.review_id LEFT JOIN `user__reviews` AS `ur` ON ur.review_id = r.review_id LEFT JOIN `movie__reviews` AS `mr` ON mr.review_id = r.review_id WHERE (1 AND mr.`movie_id` = 43 AND r.`staff_review_id` IS NOT NULL AND r.is_published_review = 1 AND r.is_deleted_review = 0) GROUP BY `1`
  6. [130.23 ms] SELECT DISTINCT `rg`.* FROM `review_genres` AS `rg` LEFT JOIN `reviews` AS `r` ON rg.`genre_id` = r.`genre_id` WHERE (1 AND r.`review_type_id` = 7 AND r.`is_published_review` = 1 AND r.`is_deleted_review` = 0) ORDER BY `rg`.`genre_name` ASC

File Information

137 Files Included
Total Size: 1378K
Basepath: /mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/settings/../../../

Application Files

/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/Bootstrap.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/modules/default/models/Assistant.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/modules/default/models/Filters.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/modules/reviews/controllers/ReviewsController.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/modules/reviews/models/Movies.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/modules/reviews/models/ReviewGenres.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/modules/reviews/models/Reviews.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/modules/users/models/Users.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/settings/config.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/system/acl.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/application/frontend/system/routes.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/App/Controller/Plugin/Acl.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/App/Controller/Plugin/AjaxCheck.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/App/Controller/Plugin/AutoLogin.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/App/Controller/Plugin/FlashMessenger.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/App/Controller/Plugin/InmailMessageCount.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/App/View/Serializer.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/App/View/Xslt.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/www/index.php

Zend Library Files

/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Acl.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Acl/Assert/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Acl/Exception.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Acl/Resource.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Acl/Resource/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Acl/Role.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Acl/Role/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Acl/Role/Registry.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Acl/Role/Registry/Exception.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Auth.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Auth/Storage/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Auth/Storage/Session.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Cache.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Cache/Backend.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Cache/Backend/ExtendedInterface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Cache/Backend/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Cache/Backend/Memcached.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Cache/Core.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Config.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Action.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Action/Helper/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Action/Helper/FlashMessenger.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Action/Helper/ViewRenderer.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Action/HelperBroker.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Action/HelperBroker/PriorityStack.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Action/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Dispatcher/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Dispatcher/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Dispatcher/Standard.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Exception.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Front.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Plugin/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Plugin/Broker.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Plugin/ErrorHandler.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Request/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Request/Http.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Response/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Response/Http.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Router/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Router/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Router/Rewrite.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Router/Route.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Router/Route/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Router/Route/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Router/Route/Module.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Controller/Router/Route/Regex.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Adapter/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Adapter/Pdo/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Adapter/Pdo/Mysql.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Expr.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Profiler.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Profiler/Query.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Select.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Statement.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Statement/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Statement/Pdo.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Db/Table/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Exception.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Filter.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Filter/Inflector.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Filter/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Filter/PregReplace.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Filter/StringToLower.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Filter/Word/CamelCaseToDash.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Filter/Word/CamelCaseToSeparator.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Filter/Word/Separator/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Filter/Word/SeparatorToSeparator.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Filter/Word/UnderscoreToSeparator.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Form.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Loader.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Loader/Autoloader.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Loader/PluginLoader.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Loader/PluginLoader/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Locale.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Locale/Data/Translation.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Log.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Log/Filter/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Log/Filter/Priority.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Log/Formatter/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Log/Formatter/Simple.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Log/Writer/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Log/Writer/Stream.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Registry.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Session.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Session/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Session/Exception.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Session/Namespace.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Session/SaveHandler/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Translate.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Translate/Adapter.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Translate/Adapter/Gettext.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Uri.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Validate/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/Version.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View/Helper/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View/Helper/HeadMeta.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View/Helper/HeadTitle.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View/Helper/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View/Helper/Placeholder/Container.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View/Helper/Placeholder/Container/Abstract.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View/Helper/Placeholder/Container/Standalone.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View/Helper/Placeholder/Registry.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/Zend/View/Interface.php

ZFDebug Library Files

/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin/Database.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin/Exception.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin/File.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin/Html.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin/Interface.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin/Memory.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin/Registry.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin/Text.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin/Time.php
/mnt/fs.9/disk1/local/www/filmnet/library/ZFDebug/Controller/Plugin/Debug/Plugin/Variables.php

Memory Usage

Controller: 2901.73K

Custom Timers

Controller: 402.31 ms

Overall Timers

reviews
reviews
detail
Avg: 925.35 ms / 1 requests
Min: 925.35 ms
Max: 925.35 ms

Reset timers by sending ZFDEBUG_RESET as a GET/POST parameter

Registered Instances

Zend_View_Helper_Placeholder_Registry => Zend_View_Helper_Placeholder_Registry Object()
acl => Zend_Acl Object()
baseDir => 'http://www.filmnet.com/'
cache => Zend_Cache_Core Object()
config => Zend_Config Object()
db => Zend_Db_Adapter_Pdo_Mysql Object()
translator => Zend_Translate Object()
copyright 1.8.0/5.2.10-2ubuntu6variables Variableshtml HTMLdatabase 6 in 280.86 msfile 137 Filesmemory 12998K of 1024Mtime 925.35 msregistry Registry (7)«